07/11/05
English
cereal beef producers could double their gross margins by feeding
head-cut wheat alkalage in place of rolled barley, according to
the latest English Beef and Lamb Executive (EBLEX) trials. And
the potential gains may be even greater for heifer finishers, given
the diet’s apparent ability to reduce carcase fat levels.
The trials, conducted by Harper Adams University College with
Belgian Blue x Holstein bulls and heifers reared from 265kg, compared
rolled barley rations from conventionally-harvested grain with
diets based on harvesting the top 20-25 cm of wheat crops at approximately
70% dry matter, cracking the grains and ensiling them with a urea-based
additive.
Both bulls and heifers finished on this cracked head-cut urea-treated
(CHCUT) wholecrop wheat took longer to reach slaughter condition
than those on rolled barley. However, they recorded heavier liveweights
at slaughter and heavier carcase weights. The fact that CHCUT wheat-fed
heifers, in particular, recorded significantly lower carcase fat
levels suggests the diet offers the opportunity to take them to
heavier weights without becoming over-fat, so avoiding under-weight
penalties.
The daily dry matter intakes of both bulls and heifers fed CHCUT
wholecrop wheat were higher than those on rolled barley, and the
feed conversion efficiencies lower. Nevertheless, very much lower
unit feed costs - £63/t DM for the wholecrop wheat ration
vs £107t/DM for the barley mix – meant valuable economies
in cost per kg carcase gain.
Across all the animals, therefore, the gross margin for CHCUT
wholecrop wheat feeding at £58/head was almost double that
of the rolled barley at £30/head. Although the longer feeding
period reduced the gross margin/head/year advantage, very much
higher yields from the wheat meant an overall gross margin/ha more
than double the rolled barley regime.
Head Cut Alkalage Trial Results (Harper Adams 2005)
Average of Bulls and
Heifers |
Rolled
Barley |
CHCUT
Wholecrop Wheat |
Finishing period (days) |
181 |
230 |
Liveweight gain (kg/day) |
1.29 |
1.12 |
Carcase weight (kg) |
275 |
285 |
Fatness score |
3.44 |
2.83 |
Feed cost (p/kg carcase gain) |
94 |
81 |
Gross Margin (£/head) * |
30 |
58 |
Gross Margin (£/head/year)* |
55 |
92 |
Gross Margin (£/ha)* |
168 |
343 |
* Excluding headage payments or SFP
In addition to these direct benefits, EBLEX suggests the potential
for head-cut alkalage to increase cereal dry matter yields improve
cropping flexibility, simplify cereal storage and processing and
reduce the risk of digestive disorders make the system well worth
exploring for many English producers.
A copy of the ‘Alkalage Project Final Report’ can
be found on the EBLEX website www.eblex.org.uk
Market
Study Quantifies Farm Assured Beef Value
The French Are Coming! - English Beef Exports |