02/11/05
Consumers and politicians are being urged by Scotland's
farming union to join the campaign to tackle the increasing power
of the supermarkets. NFU Scotland is reiterating its call for
urgent political action as some Scottish farmers start taking
strike action and withholding produce to protest at unsustainable
farmgate prices. A three-day strike has been organised by Farmers
For Action starting today.
For a year now, NFUS has been urging Government and the Competition
Authorities to tackle the imbalance of power within the food
and drink supply chain which has seen supermarket margins increase
on the back of reducing prices to farmers. NFUS is calling for
a further Competition Commission investigation into the retail
sector and the introduction of an independent watchdog to police
fair trade between UK supermarkets and their suppliers.
NFUS has emphasised that some supermarket and supplier relationships
work very well, but there is too much fear in the supply chain
and there is no means of tackling abuses of power.
NFUS meetings with politicians at Holyrood start tomorrow and
come ahead of action on Saturday when farmers will be speaking
to shoppers around the country. Farmers will be in supermarkets
highlighting the growing gap between the shelf price and the
price paid to them (see notes for examples). Farmers will also
be at some farmers markets thanking shoppers for their support
for the markets and local produce and urging them to put pressure
on politicians to address the power of the supermarkets.
NFUS President John Kinnaird said:
"As supermarket margins have grown, farmers have faced
a destructive squeeze on their own businesses. Farmers are now
saying enough is enough. It has now got to the point that farmers
are starting strike action; withholding produce to protest at
the unsustainable prices they are being paid. Many farmers are
simply not in a position to take part in a strike as it adds
to an already serious financial situation and causes real problems
for those committed to supply contracts. Yet, the fact this is
even being talked about should be a clear message that the current
situation cannot continue.
"If supermarkets want to continue to increase their margins
at farmers' expense, they could destroy much of our local
food industry. We are already seeing local food processing facilities
close and the financial squeeze which has seen a quarter of Scotland's
dairy farms quit in the last five years is now being felt across
all sectors of agriculture.
"The First Minister has recognised this problem and has
already highlighted to supermarkets that they will be starved
of supply if they starve farmers of a fair price. We now need
action. I have already discussed this issue with Mr McConnell
and tomorrow I begin a series of meetings with the major political
parties.
"Around 80 per cent of the food and drink produced in
this country is sold through the major supermarkets and the misuse
of power must be addressed if we want to secure the future of
Scotland's world famous food industry."
- The three day strike is being organised by Farmers
For Action.
- NFUS is stressing that supermarket
shoppers should not have to pay more at the tills to ensure
farmers receive a sustainable price. There is enough in the
supermarkets' shelf price to ensure everyone can make a living.
The following examples highlight the gap between supermarket
shelf price and farmgate price:
- Milk is sold in supermarkets
for around 54 pence per litre, farmers are paid 18 pence.
- Potatoes
are sold for around £550
per tonne in supermarkets, farmers are paid £95.
- Carrots
are sold in supermarkets for around £700 per tonne, farmers
are paid £80.
- Beef is sold in supermarkets for an average
of £4.25p/kg, farmers are paid around £1.90p/kg.
- Porridge
oats are sold for around £570 per tonne in
supermarkets, farmer are paid £70.
- Strawberries are
sold for around £3.00
per pound in supermarkets, farmers are paid £1.30.
- One
in four of Scotland's family dairy farms (700 businesses)
have quit in the last six years. They receive around 18 pence
per litre of milk produced. It costs around 19 pence to produce.
There are 1450 dairy farms left in Scotland and the UK is forecast
to face a milk shortage of one billion litres by 2007.
- Three
years ago, the Office of Fair Trading introduced a supermarket
code of practice to ensure fair trade between the big four
supermarkets. Not a single complaint has ever been formally
lodged under the code because of the fear amongst suppliers
of being de-listed if they complain at supermarket trading
tactics.
- NFUS
conducted its own inquiry this summer with Scotland major food
and drink processors. Whilst some were very positive about
their relationship with supermarkets, NFUS was given alarming
evidence of abuses of power and breaches of the Code. All evidence
was submitted on condition of the strictest confidentiality.
NFUS uncovered the following practices:
- Loyalty payments
(also known as slotting fees, charged to buy shelf space)
are still demanded by major supermarkets. Non payment can
result in the loss of business.
- The fees charged for artwork and
re-packaging of supermarket products are enforced on suppliers
and not negotiated.
- Supermarkets like to 'manage' the
public statements of their suppliers.
- The re-negotiation
of supermarket contracts is not always determined by price
and quality of service. There is evidence that contracts
can be awarded to a supplier's competitor simply to reduce
the original supplier's negotiating power and to maintain
the supermarket dominant position.
Disease Levy Proposal Unacceptable SAC
Report Highlights Green Fuel Potential
OFT Blow to Dairy Industry Development
|